r-labs » Code Review

なんだか難しそうな要望がいろいろ。
---
Your work is very promising, but it does not really fit my needs as is.
Here are some points :

• I think that having one "Review" (in the list) per comment is far too much
• I think that commenting right from the diff view is simple but to systematic (even if it may be solved with rights)

To my mind a code review is :

• a list of file diffs (why not having a creation process with start/end path and revisions ?)
• reviewed by several guys (not only the author)
• finally acknowledged by someone (the project manager ?)

While waiting for your point of view please accept my best greatings for your work !
---
http://www.redmine.org/boards/3/topics/5878#message-5891